Does BVB need a new coach? Yes, some say, 2 years of “decline” are enough (downward tendency would describe it better), No, some get het up, the coach is a 100% Borussian and the team is the problem.
Both parties know that they hit dead centre. On the one side Matthias Sammer didn’t managed to create a team out of many individuals. Is the team structure exposed to pressure, it collapses way too fast. Maybe Sammer was right in summer 2002: “The Bundesliga title happened to early!” Surely this championship did its part that some players of the squad thought they are the greatest. Starting with Amoroso, who showed aris and graces that would do no good to any team. Especially in dealing with Amoroso Sammer seemed to be swamped, but also the support of the club wasn’t there as Niebaum and Meier feared that Amoroso as an asset would lose in value. When Amoroso talked dirty about the coach and even the medical staff, the club officials didn’t do anything especially not legal measures. These finally followed this year and after 2 years of fuss and false accusations he was gone. Sammer as a coach got damaged for the first – maybe also inside the team. But not only Amoroso made regresses since 2002, also premium talents, like Kehl and Rosicky, performances got worse. While Kehl got better during the return leg of the Bundesliga, Rosicky is on his way down.
While other coaches every now and then integrate talents, Sammer needed the big injury crisis in the first leg of the 2003/2004 season to give the youth a chance. However not because he wanted to motivate the stars or boost the youth. Just because there were so many injured players (sg.com: up to 15!). Together with the sporting management “big signings” like Jensen and Bergdolmo were done during last summer, without having an adequate position for this players. Jensen had to play as a left-back, even though his strengths are in a more offensive role, and Bergdolmo wasn’t used very often on his best position as a right- or left-back. Instead he played as a central defender and showed too often, that that is not his position.
A talent like Stefan Hoffmann, who had been praised during last summer’s training camp and who played an important role at BVB’s Amateur team, hadn’t any Bundesliga minute due to coach Sammer. Gambino, shining at the Amateurs, was recognised very late and then got playing time in the Bundesliga team. At that moment many (self-declared!) experts shook their heads, why Sammer had brought on this young talent so late. He later showed how important he can be and already is. Senesie showed little of his talent and maybe needs some more time. Krontiris, 2 years ago named by Sammer THE talent of BVB’s youth, was loaned to Alemannia Aachen and probably won’t return. In this case it is up to the player as he already at BVB sometimes showed that he hasn’t got the will to get to the top. The question Matthias Sammer has now to answer is why he didn’t substituted established players, that apparently acted in a half-hearted way, with young talents even before the injury misery. What is working at other clubs should also be possible at BVB regarding our “oh, so” excellent youth education system (there was next to no impact to the professional team since Ricken), or not? Maybe this new impulse would have improved the established players performances!? Especially young players were the ones that brought us through the period of an unbelievable number of injuries, while the one or other established player didn’t help the team.
Also the question must be allowed, why he gives the players so often perfect alibis. Initiated by him there are too often discussions with the referee, while the team forgets to concentrate on their main business – football. It’s the same with talking about the bad pitch and the psychological turn-around at home against Real Madrid (sg.com: where we got the equaliser in the 93th minute and thus didn’t proceeded to the quarter finals).
Many supporters blame him that we haven’t won a Derby (sg.com: matches against Schlacke 05) since 4 years – out of them 2 of the devastating defeats of the past 15 years. Especially Sammer talked before the Derbies of “normal matches” thus taking the spice out of these duels. Not once since Sammer is coach in Dortmund the matches between Dortmund and Schlacke were full of emotions on the pitch. Not one single time the players realised what this Derbies mean to the fans of Borussia.
On the other side Matthias Sammer is on eof the last persons that fully identifies with the club. He is always giving 100%. For those who blame him for being lazy or disinterested – shut up. As well you treat him unfair, when you think Sammer sticks to his job because he wants full compensation if the club fires him. That are accusations that simply didn’t match with Sammer’s character, which he has shown over 11 years in Dortmund.
But the biggest argument pro-Sammer is the following one: Firing the coach would strengthen the much criticised mentality of the team. Surely this would be a perfect new alibi for the players. This time it wouldn’t be the psychological turn-around Real, the bad pitch, the even weaker referee or the huge list of injuries – the stupid coach would be the icing on the cake! From this point of view getting grid of the coach wouldn’t be an option , because the new coach would immediately deal with the same problems. The critics of the coach on the other hand say that especially now that there will be changes in the squad it is time for a new coach.
Who is right now? As already mentioned post sides have their points and the arguments seem logical. Sammer for sure hasn’t done everything right in the near past. On the other side this was the risk BVB accepted from the beginning. You can’t expect a young coach to have the experience of a proven one. So what is the right position? Is Sammer still the one to command the BVB ship? Is he able to bring the team, which itself will change, to better performances again? Or is he at his wits’ end and a separation would be better for both sides? This decision we as supporters can’t make without having a queasy feeling, this is up to people that are even closer to the action, the team and coach, simply the officials of the club. But one thing should be clear for all of us: Matthias Sammer has, after 11,5 years at Borussia, great successes as a player and a coach and a honest behaviour on and off the pitch from the beginning, deserved to be treated in a fair way. The polemics towards him that are now upcoming are absolutely unfair.
Geschrieben von Jens/Arne