Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA will held their financial statement press conference for the fiscal year 2003/2004 this upcoming Friday, the 8th of October 2004 (http://www.borussia-aktie.de/). The company is currently going through a hard time and the two main people in charge, president Dr. Gerd Niebaum and manager Michael Meier, will have to answer a lot of tough questions. Since Borussia is now a public company they have to issue balance sheets and profit and loss statements on a regular basis. So on the one side the club (or you could say the company) is more transparent, but on the other side it is difficult for the ?normal football fan? to understand the financial processes and the consequences to the football club.
Schwatzgelb.com therefore decided to publish the work of Frank Guennemann as a guest author article to get a better understanding of what these financial figures are made of and what the impact is. Frank is a BVB supporter since more than 12 years. He studied International Business Administration and worked as a assistant to general management. Currently he is working on his MBA (Master of Business Administration) at the Hawaii Pacific University.
The paper was a project for his Accounting class. The class members had to choose a company, analyse it with regards to the current annual report (balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement) and make a recommendation to the chosen target audience (potential investors). However, it was limited to only 5 pages so that Frank really had to focus solely on the facts and numbers given in the annual report of 2003, neglecting current news and developments. Therefore the report is based on the numbers issued by Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA!
Guest author article by Frank Guennemann
This paper is a financial statement analysis of Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA, a German soccer club listed at the German stock exchange. The analysis consists of five parts; i.e. the introduction, which describes the outline of the paper; the focus, which introduces the company, identifies the target audience, the alternative courses of action, and the decision to be made; the analysis of the three primary statements (the company?s balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement); the conclusion which draws on the findings of the analysis; and finally a recommendation for the target audience including important additional information about the nature of the soccer business and its related risks.
Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA (hereinafter ?Borussia?), is one of the leading companies in the field of professional international soccer. For its core business is professional soccer, Borussia generates most of its revenue from sponsoring, ticketing, the sale of TV rights, and merchandising. This analysis shall be a consultancy for potential investors (i.e. shareholders). For this target audience there are two possible alternatives, either to invest in the company?s share or not to invest. In order to fulfill the task of a good consultancy, the emphasis of this analysis shall lay on evaluating the company?s financial performance by sticking to facts given in its 2003 annual report, and only those numbers and ratios which are available and appropriate for the target audience shall be used. Thereafter, a decision, which draws on these findings, is made to either invest or not. The outcome will be not to invest in Borussia?s shares for several reasons.
a) The Balance Sheet
Current ratio
= current assets / current liabilities One important measure for a company?s performance is the current ratio, which equals current assets divided by current liabilities (see appendix). For Borussia, it would be ?115,725,939 / ?39,651,000 = 2.92 for the year of 2003. The current ratio is a measure of the company?s liquidity and a somewhat degree of safety against fluctuations in the flow of funds, for Borussia this seems to be a sound basis, since its current assets consist of merchandise (?623,000), accounts receivable (?43,637,000), securities (?1,460,000), and cash on hand (?70,006,000), all of which are easily convertible to cash and thus liquidity. Compared to the 2002 and 2001 current ratios, which were ?105,929,225 / ?36,013,000 = 2.94 in 2002 and ?112,292,100 / ?38,555,000 = 2.91 in 2001, this ratio is quite stable, which represents sound financial basis to meet current obligations.
Financial leverage ratio
= total assets / shareholder?s equity The financial leverage ratio measures a company?s level of debt by dividing total assets by shareholder?s equity, which shows the extent to which the company relies on debt financing. A value of 1.0 means that the company has no debt; thus the higher the ratio, the higher the debt. Borussia?s financial leverage ratio in 2003 is ?239,282,647 / ?149,359,846 = 1.6, representing not only an increased level of debt but also a continuous rise for the last two years (in 2002: ?222,490,545 / ?148,536,348 = 1.5 and in 2001: ?215,002,300 / ?147,131,700 = 1.4). This is a cause for concern, since a high ratio indicates possible difficulty in paying interest and principal while obtaining more funding.
b)The Income Statement
Return on Equity
(ROE) = net income / shareholders? equity ROE shows how much a company has earned on its shareholders investments by dividing net income by shareholders? equity. Borussia?s ROE in 2003 is ?823,499 / ?149,359,846 = 0.005, a very poor result. However, in previous years the result was equally poor (in 2002: ?1,404,630 / ?148,536,348 = 0.009, in 2001: ?-9,012,500 / ?147,131,700 = -0.06), thus there seems to be a big problem and a cause for concerns, especially regarding the highly unattractiveness for investors.
Equity turnover
= sales / shareholders' equity This is a company's sales divided by its shareholders' equity and used to calculate the rate of return on equity, basically a measure of how well a company uses its shareholders' equity to generate revenue. The higher the ratio is, the more efficiently a company is using its capital. For Borussia, this is ?124,418,559 / ?149,359,846 = 0.83 times in 2003, which is a quite low value, signaling that it is using its funds rather inefficiently. However, compared to the years 2002 (?102,358,194 / ?148,536,348 = 0.69) and 2001 (?76,984,200 / ?147,131,700 = 0.52) the situation is slightly improving.
Interest coverage ratio
= pre-tax income before interest divided / interest Another important means to measure a company?s financial soundness is the interest coverage ratio, which equals pre-tax income before interest divided by interest. In Borussia?s case, this is ?916,184 / ?3,396,585 = 0.3, meaning that 2003?s income was 0.3 times its interest requirements, while in 2002 it was 0.7 times (?1,458,486 / ?2,172,897). Thus, there was a steep decline in profits (due to lost revenue because of missing to qualify for the ?UEFA Champions League? in the 2002/03 season), but a large increase in interest payments. Although compared to 2001 (?-8,954,500 / ?2,068,800 = -4.3) the situation is a lot better now, a still increasing amount in interest is a cause to concern, especially when knowing that at the end of the 2003 season Borussia yet again missed to qualify for an international tournament which basically represents a chance of generating a huge income.
c) The Cash Flow Statement
The cash flow statement consists of three categories: operating activities, investing activities, and financing activities. Borussia?s cash flow for each of these categories varies significantly; i.e. the operating cash flow shows a negative ?3,182,000 (compared to a positive ?11,684,000 in 2002), the investing activities cash flow also shows a negative ?7,348,000 (compared to a negative ?21,203,000), and the financing activities cash flow shows a positive ?17,175,000 (compared to a positive ?9,044,000), resulting in a positive cash flow of ?6,645,000. Added to this are ?64,742,000 cash on hand from the start of the period, resulting in liquid funds of ?71,387,000.
Cash realization ratio
= cash generated by operations / net income One way to analyze a company?s cash flow is the cash realization ratio, which measures the quality of net income, i.e. net income realized in cash. Borussia?s cash realization ratio (cash generated by operations divided by net income) for the year 2003 is ? -3,182,000 / ?823,499 = -3.86. Since a ratio higher than one indicates high-quality earnings, in this case the result is again very poor. Compared to the year 2002, the ratio was ?11,684,000 / ?1,404,630 = 0.83, thus the situation has worsened dramatically (no data on the year 2001 available).
Cash flow to debt ratio = (net income + depreciation) / total debt The cash flow to debt ratio is used to analyze possible liquidity problems. Since debt does not materialize as a liquidity problem until its due date, the closer to maturity, the greater liquidity should be. The company?s cash flow (i.e. the sum of net income plus depreciation) is divided by total debt. In Borussia?s case, ?31,958,000 / ?79,444,801 = 0.4, a rather poor result which may lead to liquidity problems in the near future.
As can be seen in the evaluation table, Borussia Dortmund?s financial performance is a cause for concern and investing in its shares is highly risky. Although Borussia has overall a good current ratio and reasonable cash flow (i.e. good liquidity and safety against fluctuations in the flow of funds), negative aspects, however, outweigh these pros. Increasing levels of debt (financial leverage and cash flow to debt ratios), as well as an overall poor performance in the use of funds and realization of cash (ROE, equity turnover, and cash realization ratios) pose immense cause for concern. Another aspect is the company?s impressive staff costs (professional soccer players) totaling nearly ?68 million, compared to a significant loss in cash generated by operations and a possible loss of revenue due to missed qualification for European competitions at the end of the 2003 season. Thus, the only rational conclusion is not to invest in Borussia?s shares.
Based on the analysis on hand, it is clear to see that Borussia suffers from increasing financial performance problems. However, in order to make an appropriate recommendation, it is also important to know some additional information about the company?s business; special risk factors should be carefully considered by investors along with the information given in the analysis. A major drawback is the fact that the company depends on continuous success of the professional soccer team, and major financial investments in players do not guarantee success (a lesson learned recently by Borussia). A lack of sporting success (e.g. missing qualifications for European competitions) adversely affects the company?s revenues through a loss of income from the UEFA, TV rights and ticket sales, which would hurt the shares? market value. Hence, investors would lose significant portions of their investments, and even more so in case Borussia were relegated from its national league. These factors influence the market value of the share. Ever since the IPO, the price fell from about ?11.00 to an all-time low in 2003 and 2004 of under ?3.00 (see chart in the appendix), due to (1) a weak financial performance, (2) external events and factors (changes in the professional soccer industry), and (3) lack of sporting success and international presence. Thus, at this time it is not recommendable to invest in Borussia Dortmund shares.
a) Chart of Borussia Dortmund?s share performance
b) Borussia?s Balance Sheet, Income Statement, and Cash Flow Statement
Geschrieben von Frank Guennemann
Schwatzgelb.com therefore decided to publish the work of Frank Guennemann as a guest author article to get a better understanding of what these financial figures are made of and what the impact is. Frank is a BVB supporter since more than 12 years. He studied International Business Administration and worked as a assistant to general management. Currently he is working on his MBA (Master of Business Administration) at the Hawaii Pacific University.
The paper was a project for his Accounting class. The class members had to choose a company, analyse it with regards to the current annual report (balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement) and make a recommendation to the chosen target audience (potential investors). However, it was limited to only 5 pages so that Frank really had to focus solely on the facts and numbers given in the annual report of 2003, neglecting current news and developments. Therefore the report is based on the numbers issued by Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA!
Guest author article by Frank Guennemann
This paper is a financial statement analysis of Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA, a German soccer club listed at the German stock exchange. The analysis consists of five parts; i.e. the introduction, which describes the outline of the paper; the focus, which introduces the company, identifies the target audience, the alternative courses of action, and the decision to be made; the analysis of the three primary statements (the company?s balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement); the conclusion which draws on the findings of the analysis; and finally a recommendation for the target audience including important additional information about the nature of the soccer business and its related risks.
Borussia Dortmund GmbH & Co. KGaA (hereinafter ?Borussia?), is one of the leading companies in the field of professional international soccer. For its core business is professional soccer, Borussia generates most of its revenue from sponsoring, ticketing, the sale of TV rights, and merchandising. This analysis shall be a consultancy for potential investors (i.e. shareholders). For this target audience there are two possible alternatives, either to invest in the company?s share or not to invest. In order to fulfill the task of a good consultancy, the emphasis of this analysis shall lay on evaluating the company?s financial performance by sticking to facts given in its 2003 annual report, and only those numbers and ratios which are available and appropriate for the target audience shall be used. Thereafter, a decision, which draws on these findings, is made to either invest or not. The outcome will be not to invest in Borussia?s shares for several reasons.
a) The Balance Sheet
Current ratio
= current assets / current liabilities One important measure for a company?s performance is the current ratio, which equals current assets divided by current liabilities (see appendix). For Borussia, it would be ?115,725,939 / ?39,651,000 = 2.92 for the year of 2003. The current ratio is a measure of the company?s liquidity and a somewhat degree of safety against fluctuations in the flow of funds, for Borussia this seems to be a sound basis, since its current assets consist of merchandise (?623,000), accounts receivable (?43,637,000), securities (?1,460,000), and cash on hand (?70,006,000), all of which are easily convertible to cash and thus liquidity. Compared to the 2002 and 2001 current ratios, which were ?105,929,225 / ?36,013,000 = 2.94 in 2002 and ?112,292,100 / ?38,555,000 = 2.91 in 2001, this ratio is quite stable, which represents sound financial basis to meet current obligations.
Financial leverage ratio
= total assets / shareholder?s equity The financial leverage ratio measures a company?s level of debt by dividing total assets by shareholder?s equity, which shows the extent to which the company relies on debt financing. A value of 1.0 means that the company has no debt; thus the higher the ratio, the higher the debt. Borussia?s financial leverage ratio in 2003 is ?239,282,647 / ?149,359,846 = 1.6, representing not only an increased level of debt but also a continuous rise for the last two years (in 2002: ?222,490,545 / ?148,536,348 = 1.5 and in 2001: ?215,002,300 / ?147,131,700 = 1.4). This is a cause for concern, since a high ratio indicates possible difficulty in paying interest and principal while obtaining more funding.
b)The Income Statement
Return on Equity
(ROE) = net income / shareholders? equity ROE shows how much a company has earned on its shareholders investments by dividing net income by shareholders? equity. Borussia?s ROE in 2003 is ?823,499 / ?149,359,846 = 0.005, a very poor result. However, in previous years the result was equally poor (in 2002: ?1,404,630 / ?148,536,348 = 0.009, in 2001: ?-9,012,500 / ?147,131,700 = -0.06), thus there seems to be a big problem and a cause for concerns, especially regarding the highly unattractiveness for investors.
Equity turnover
= sales / shareholders' equity This is a company's sales divided by its shareholders' equity and used to calculate the rate of return on equity, basically a measure of how well a company uses its shareholders' equity to generate revenue. The higher the ratio is, the more efficiently a company is using its capital. For Borussia, this is ?124,418,559 / ?149,359,846 = 0.83 times in 2003, which is a quite low value, signaling that it is using its funds rather inefficiently. However, compared to the years 2002 (?102,358,194 / ?148,536,348 = 0.69) and 2001 (?76,984,200 / ?147,131,700 = 0.52) the situation is slightly improving.
Interest coverage ratio
= pre-tax income before interest divided / interest Another important means to measure a company?s financial soundness is the interest coverage ratio, which equals pre-tax income before interest divided by interest. In Borussia?s case, this is ?916,184 / ?3,396,585 = 0.3, meaning that 2003?s income was 0.3 times its interest requirements, while in 2002 it was 0.7 times (?1,458,486 / ?2,172,897). Thus, there was a steep decline in profits (due to lost revenue because of missing to qualify for the ?UEFA Champions League? in the 2002/03 season), but a large increase in interest payments. Although compared to 2001 (?-8,954,500 / ?2,068,800 = -4.3) the situation is a lot better now, a still increasing amount in interest is a cause to concern, especially when knowing that at the end of the 2003 season Borussia yet again missed to qualify for an international tournament which basically represents a chance of generating a huge income.
c) The Cash Flow Statement
The cash flow statement consists of three categories: operating activities, investing activities, and financing activities. Borussia?s cash flow for each of these categories varies significantly; i.e. the operating cash flow shows a negative ?3,182,000 (compared to a positive ?11,684,000 in 2002), the investing activities cash flow also shows a negative ?7,348,000 (compared to a negative ?21,203,000), and the financing activities cash flow shows a positive ?17,175,000 (compared to a positive ?9,044,000), resulting in a positive cash flow of ?6,645,000. Added to this are ?64,742,000 cash on hand from the start of the period, resulting in liquid funds of ?71,387,000.
Cash realization ratio
= cash generated by operations / net income One way to analyze a company?s cash flow is the cash realization ratio, which measures the quality of net income, i.e. net income realized in cash. Borussia?s cash realization ratio (cash generated by operations divided by net income) for the year 2003 is ? -3,182,000 / ?823,499 = -3.86. Since a ratio higher than one indicates high-quality earnings, in this case the result is again very poor. Compared to the year 2002, the ratio was ?11,684,000 / ?1,404,630 = 0.83, thus the situation has worsened dramatically (no data on the year 2001 available).
Cash flow to debt ratio = (net income + depreciation) / total debt The cash flow to debt ratio is used to analyze possible liquidity problems. Since debt does not materialize as a liquidity problem until its due date, the closer to maturity, the greater liquidity should be. The company?s cash flow (i.e. the sum of net income plus depreciation) is divided by total debt. In Borussia?s case, ?31,958,000 / ?79,444,801 = 0.4, a rather poor result which may lead to liquidity problems in the near future.
As can be seen in the evaluation table, Borussia Dortmund?s financial performance is a cause for concern and investing in its shares is highly risky. Although Borussia has overall a good current ratio and reasonable cash flow (i.e. good liquidity and safety against fluctuations in the flow of funds), negative aspects, however, outweigh these pros. Increasing levels of debt (financial leverage and cash flow to debt ratios), as well as an overall poor performance in the use of funds and realization of cash (ROE, equity turnover, and cash realization ratios) pose immense cause for concern. Another aspect is the company?s impressive staff costs (professional soccer players) totaling nearly ?68 million, compared to a significant loss in cash generated by operations and a possible loss of revenue due to missed qualification for European competitions at the end of the 2003 season. Thus, the only rational conclusion is not to invest in Borussia?s shares.
Based on the analysis on hand, it is clear to see that Borussia suffers from increasing financial performance problems. However, in order to make an appropriate recommendation, it is also important to know some additional information about the company?s business; special risk factors should be carefully considered by investors along with the information given in the analysis. A major drawback is the fact that the company depends on continuous success of the professional soccer team, and major financial investments in players do not guarantee success (a lesson learned recently by Borussia). A lack of sporting success (e.g. missing qualifications for European competitions) adversely affects the company?s revenues through a loss of income from the UEFA, TV rights and ticket sales, which would hurt the shares? market value. Hence, investors would lose significant portions of their investments, and even more so in case Borussia were relegated from its national league. These factors influence the market value of the share. Ever since the IPO, the price fell from about ?11.00 to an all-time low in 2003 and 2004 of under ?3.00 (see chart in the appendix), due to (1) a weak financial performance, (2) external events and factors (changes in the professional soccer industry), and (3) lack of sporting success and international presence. Thus, at this time it is not recommendable to invest in Borussia Dortmund shares.
a) Chart of Borussia Dortmund?s share performance
b) Borussia?s Balance Sheet, Income Statement, and Cash Flow Statement
Geschrieben von Frank Guennemann