No day without new rumours about the financial situation of Borussia. Schwatzgelb.de talked with Stefan ten Doornkaat from the protection society of capital investors (SdK). He is expecting deep red numbers for the BVB at the next balance sheet press conference.
Schwatzgelb.de: Mr. ten Doornkaat. You are representing the interest of the so called small stock investors. About how many people are we talking with respect to Borussia Dortmund KgaA and about which share of the stocks?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: The protection society of the small stock owners e.V. is part of the German federal association (the so called Bundesverband) of the consumer right groups. Because of that many of small stock owners which can not join the shareholders meeting can be represented by SdK. The number of the shares are different and changes every time. But it is enough to protect the rights of the stock owners.
Schwatzgelb.de: You have asked in article at the beginning of this year in the ?Süddeutschen? newspaper for consequences and announced to ask for a special audit of the balance sheet. What happened to this special audit? Another newspaper, the TAZ, called you a lithe wimp because nothing happened.
Stefan ten Doornkaat: You can only request a special balance sheet audit during the shareholders meeting. Also I have an agreement with Mr. Meier that the board of directors of Borussia Dortmund KgaA will give the order for a financial certification. If this will not be provided till the shareholders meeting then I will ask for a special audit. Also the financial situation should not be burden with the costs of a special extraordinary general meeting. These costs can be up too one million Euro. You can save this money and maybe get a new defender with perspective for the club.
Schwatzgelb.de: During the summer break one theme had specially heat up the soul of the fans. The right of the names regarding the Westfalenstadion should have been sold from the BVB to a subsidiary of the Commerzbank for five million Euro, and were then bought back during the summer. The Hamburger SV is getting approximately three million Euro every year! From ?AOL? for his arena. How can that be and why is Borussia not taking a normal credit if it only is a question of getting short term cash?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: You are mention a point which for my is also not clear. BVB is selling his name rights for the next four years for only five million Euro, although the HSV is getting around three million every year. But on the other hand it is really a short term credit business.
I would like to refer to an interview with Dr. Gerd Niebaum: ? It was a deal with a short term character. We did not wanted to make this deal in the first place. That was only an in between finance solution. A real sell of the name rights would have generate more money.?
Have you ever bought a bread with credit? The deal was, I would say, a credit! The name of the stadium was the security. You can only speculate about the reason of the credit until Mr. Dr. Niebaum and Mr. Meier explain this in public. Interesting here is that the Assunta GmbH is a subsidiary of the Commerzleasing AG, like the Molsiris KG, to which the stadium was sold to.
Schwatzgelb.de: In addition to that, the right of the names should be with ?E-ON?. Is Borussia in the position at all to sell them.
Stefan ten Doornkaat: There is a so called first buy right that belongs to the E-ON AG as the main sponsor. That means, the E-ON AG has the right to buy the name rights. If they have been sold to the Assunta GmbH then there must have been an OK by E-ON. But E-ON would have done that for free. There is currently a questions to the board of directors and also to Mr. Dr. Niebaum and Mr. Meier regarding this deal.
Schwatzgelb.de: Currently there is a new topic which goes though the media. The BVB should be paying his players late. There are speculations if the revenues from selling the season tickets, a significant number, are already spent. Without going into too much detail one is wondering that there are so many speculations since months in the media, but nobody of the journalists could proof 100% that the rumours are true. Every day you could hear or see new ones and also the denying of the club. Is the situation maybe not as bad as the ?Süddeutsche? newspaper would like us to believe? Or will we experience the next blue wonder?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: A part of the money from the advance sale has been used for rebuying the rights of the name of the stadium and interests. That was probably about 5.2 million Euros. But only Dr. Niebaum and Meier can tell us about the actual financial situation of the BVB. But they only talk about things that are not of interest. So one might wonder why none of the players should have realized that their salary is being paid later since January. And if it actually has not been paid later and there has been such an agreement since January Niebaum and Meier have to be asked why they did not pay it later. Because this would mean an advantage for their interest, as Meier has stated correctly. But the actual scandal is that one did not inform the players. If one has employees, one has contracts with them. And one has to observe those contracts. If one wants to change something in those contracts one has to communicate that in some form. After all, the player would also need to be informed in case of termination of the contract. According to the interview there has not been any communication at all.
We won?t be in for a shock, but there will deep red figures that will be made public in the balance press conference in October.
Schwatzgelb.de: That Borussia would be losing money last year without playing Champions League is no miracle. But it is strange that even in sporty successful years BVB was not successful economically. How bad is the property situation ? after all the club has more than 100 million Euros of liabilities ? and is there a problem with liquidity? Certainly our readers are not really interest if BVB will pay a dividend, but if one has to get used to the idea that Borussia will have to keep selling players in order to save the licence.
Stefan ten Doornkaat: Of course one has to distinguish between the property situation and liquidity. To keep it simple liquidity is what I have on the account. The property situation tells about the origins of the means and how they are used. Borussia Dortmund KGaA has about 270 million Euros, 120 million in principal and about 150 million Euros in liabilities. Now one has to take a look at what has been done with the money. One finds out that essentially there are the players and an amount of about 50 million Euros. If one deducts these 50 million one would have to come up to a value of 220 million Euros with the players to reach the 270 million. But in the present situation one won?t be able to reach this sum with the squad.
The 50 million Euros cannot be counted to liquidity since they are seized and must not be spent.
Schwatzgelb.de: You are talking about the property situation now. So on the one hand there is this fond which is supposed to be used for buying the stadium when the contract expires, on the other hand there is the ?running-around property?, namely the value of the players minus their depreciation. There are not many assets left after BVB has sold the stadium. Since the value of the squad is probably quite low, due to falling transfer sums, there are enormous debts, aren?t there?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: ?Running-around property? is good; I need to remember that one. Seriously it is like this: One side of the balance describes the origins of the means, or, to keep it simple: who owns the money. The other side states what one does with the money. For example, I went to the bank and loaned a credit over 1,000 Euros. Then on the passive side of the balance appears a liability of 1,000 Euros. For this money I buy a cupboard. That one appears on the active side of the balance. Because I use the cupboard its value decreases, so I use depreciations.
It is right that the transfer sums for players keep falling. The offers for Rosicky and Koller showed that. At least those were not the sums that management had calculated with. Otherwise one or two of the players would have been sold. One also has to remember that some contracts expire to the end of the season and the players would be able to change without a transfer fee.
Also true is also that I estimate the debts will rise to approximately 150 Mio Euro at the end of the last fiscal year. This estimation are based on the interim report of December 31st, 2003, which then has been extrapolated by me. This is a huge amount of debts, that has to be reduced in the future. Just regarding the interests you will see that at 8% interest rate the club has to pay 1 Mio each month or 12 Mio Euro a year. Adding to that the debts must be paid back, then there is the leasing rate of 12 to 17 Mio Euro for the stadium and the leasing back of the Goool.de brand which is 1.4 Mio Euro at minimum. Looking on a possible worst case: Then BVB have to pay 30 Mio Euro a year without having paid a single cent for player salaries and equipment. Not mentioning away matches. Whether we have to deal with over-indebtedness or not, only Dr Niebaum and Meier know, as they have the true figures. We have to wait till October to get to know the truth.
Schwatzgelb.de: Many supporters of BVB are not interested in shareholder value and financial circumstances as long as BVB show attractive football and play a major role in 1. Bundesliga. Many people are of the opinion that you are not interested in the club?s future on the pitch and think that there is something like a conspiracy against Borussia. Who do you want to explain to our users that the interests of the shareholders are the same like the ones of the supporters?
Stefan ten Doorkaat: Of course I can only speak for myself and the shareholders. We are concerned about the club?s future on the pitch as only with success the company can be turned healthy again. The question is just what is the right way to achieve this goal. Personally I favour the way VfB Stuttgart and Werder Bremen chose. Indeed BVB have another kind of tradition, but we have to realise the popularity those clubs achieved. That reminds me of BVB in the early 90?s. The finances and sporting future of BVB are in lockstep. When there is no money to be spent, I can?t afford good players. So it is definitely not a conspiracy against Borussia as I only react to the work at Rheinlanddamm (sg.com: Borussia?s headquarter). At the end the share quotation shows the degree of confidence of the shareholders in the company and its management.
Schwatzgelb.de: In one of your recent dossiers you blame Mr Meier for ?voodoo accounting? and accuse Mr Niebaum to tell fairy-tails. That?s a bit thick. Would you or will you call for the resignation of both?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: Talking about fairy-tales I can tell you that the board was addressed by me regarding an interview on the club?s own webpage ?BVB die Aktie? (sg.com: ?BVB the share?). Hereby I quoted statements of Mr Niebaum who is talking or let write about ?bridgeover financing?. To my astonishment I received a response that it wasn?t a financing deal but an ?interim solution?. It was just misunderstood by the interviewer. Adding to that the interview wasn?t authorised for going online. When I hear things like these, I am totally confused. Does Dr Niebaum give interview without making sure that the interview got everything right? Especially as this is a delicate subject, the selling of the naming rights of the Westfalenstadion. The interview is now 2 months on BVB?s homepage without being authorised? To me that sounds more like ?Gebrüder Grimm? (sg.com: Grimm brother, famous German mediaeval fairy-tellers) than a CEO of a stock-listed company.
For me ?voodoo accounting? is creating values through business, that nobody wants to fulfil. That is what happened with the stadium?s naming rights. In the mentioned interview Mr Dr Niebaum says that he doesn?t want this deal (sg.com: selling the naming rights) at all and of course not at this price. The Commerzbank just told that they have acquired the naming rights but without having made plans yet what to do with it. That is like buying a pizza and afterwards starting to think whether you are hungry or even like pizza.
Schwatzgelb.de: With exception of some supporters shouting ?Vorstand raus? (sg.com: ?board step down?) at the Wolfsburg home match the mood of the fans is still sedate. Mainly because there are not really alternatives to Mr Niebaum and Meier, there are next to no fans calling for the board to step down. Without talking about names, what qualities should a successor have? Are we talking about a complete cleaning up of the BVB KgaA? And how would that effect the future on the pitch?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: Let?s have a look at VfB Stuttgart. The were in the same situation and thought that there would not a future without former club president Gerhard Mayer-Vorfelder. Finally they found a new president and in my opinion he makes a good job. A successor has to be a true supporter of BVB, who loves the club with all his heart. At the same time he has to realise the necessity of financial recovery and should have the ability to set off a financial reorganisation. If this happens, success on the pitch will come back. Because that is clear to me: you can?t buy success, you have to work hard for it. That is in real life the same as in football, otherwise Bayern Munich with its big budget would be Bundesliga champions every single season.
Geschrieben von Guido
Schwatzgelb.de: Mr. ten Doornkaat. You are representing the interest of the so called small stock investors. About how many people are we talking with respect to Borussia Dortmund KgaA and about which share of the stocks?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: The protection society of the small stock owners e.V. is part of the German federal association (the so called Bundesverband) of the consumer right groups. Because of that many of small stock owners which can not join the shareholders meeting can be represented by SdK. The number of the shares are different and changes every time. But it is enough to protect the rights of the stock owners.
Schwatzgelb.de: You have asked in article at the beginning of this year in the ?Süddeutschen? newspaper for consequences and announced to ask for a special audit of the balance sheet. What happened to this special audit? Another newspaper, the TAZ, called you a lithe wimp because nothing happened.
Stefan ten Doornkaat: You can only request a special balance sheet audit during the shareholders meeting. Also I have an agreement with Mr. Meier that the board of directors of Borussia Dortmund KgaA will give the order for a financial certification. If this will not be provided till the shareholders meeting then I will ask for a special audit. Also the financial situation should not be burden with the costs of a special extraordinary general meeting. These costs can be up too one million Euro. You can save this money and maybe get a new defender with perspective for the club.
Schwatzgelb.de: During the summer break one theme had specially heat up the soul of the fans. The right of the names regarding the Westfalenstadion should have been sold from the BVB to a subsidiary of the Commerzbank for five million Euro, and were then bought back during the summer. The Hamburger SV is getting approximately three million Euro every year! From ?AOL? for his arena. How can that be and why is Borussia not taking a normal credit if it only is a question of getting short term cash?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: You are mention a point which for my is also not clear. BVB is selling his name rights for the next four years for only five million Euro, although the HSV is getting around three million every year. But on the other hand it is really a short term credit business.
I would like to refer to an interview with Dr. Gerd Niebaum: ? It was a deal with a short term character. We did not wanted to make this deal in the first place. That was only an in between finance solution. A real sell of the name rights would have generate more money.?
Have you ever bought a bread with credit? The deal was, I would say, a credit! The name of the stadium was the security. You can only speculate about the reason of the credit until Mr. Dr. Niebaum and Mr. Meier explain this in public. Interesting here is that the Assunta GmbH is a subsidiary of the Commerzleasing AG, like the Molsiris KG, to which the stadium was sold to.
Schwatzgelb.de: In addition to that, the right of the names should be with ?E-ON?. Is Borussia in the position at all to sell them.
Stefan ten Doornkaat: There is a so called first buy right that belongs to the E-ON AG as the main sponsor. That means, the E-ON AG has the right to buy the name rights. If they have been sold to the Assunta GmbH then there must have been an OK by E-ON. But E-ON would have done that for free. There is currently a questions to the board of directors and also to Mr. Dr. Niebaum and Mr. Meier regarding this deal.
Schwatzgelb.de: Currently there is a new topic which goes though the media. The BVB should be paying his players late. There are speculations if the revenues from selling the season tickets, a significant number, are already spent. Without going into too much detail one is wondering that there are so many speculations since months in the media, but nobody of the journalists could proof 100% that the rumours are true. Every day you could hear or see new ones and also the denying of the club. Is the situation maybe not as bad as the ?Süddeutsche? newspaper would like us to believe? Or will we experience the next blue wonder?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: A part of the money from the advance sale has been used for rebuying the rights of the name of the stadium and interests. That was probably about 5.2 million Euros. But only Dr. Niebaum and Meier can tell us about the actual financial situation of the BVB. But they only talk about things that are not of interest. So one might wonder why none of the players should have realized that their salary is being paid later since January. And if it actually has not been paid later and there has been such an agreement since January Niebaum and Meier have to be asked why they did not pay it later. Because this would mean an advantage for their interest, as Meier has stated correctly. But the actual scandal is that one did not inform the players. If one has employees, one has contracts with them. And one has to observe those contracts. If one wants to change something in those contracts one has to communicate that in some form. After all, the player would also need to be informed in case of termination of the contract. According to the interview there has not been any communication at all.
We won?t be in for a shock, but there will deep red figures that will be made public in the balance press conference in October.
Schwatzgelb.de: That Borussia would be losing money last year without playing Champions League is no miracle. But it is strange that even in sporty successful years BVB was not successful economically. How bad is the property situation ? after all the club has more than 100 million Euros of liabilities ? and is there a problem with liquidity? Certainly our readers are not really interest if BVB will pay a dividend, but if one has to get used to the idea that Borussia will have to keep selling players in order to save the licence.
Stefan ten Doornkaat: Of course one has to distinguish between the property situation and liquidity. To keep it simple liquidity is what I have on the account. The property situation tells about the origins of the means and how they are used. Borussia Dortmund KGaA has about 270 million Euros, 120 million in principal and about 150 million Euros in liabilities. Now one has to take a look at what has been done with the money. One finds out that essentially there are the players and an amount of about 50 million Euros. If one deducts these 50 million one would have to come up to a value of 220 million Euros with the players to reach the 270 million. But in the present situation one won?t be able to reach this sum with the squad.
The 50 million Euros cannot be counted to liquidity since they are seized and must not be spent.
Schwatzgelb.de: You are talking about the property situation now. So on the one hand there is this fond which is supposed to be used for buying the stadium when the contract expires, on the other hand there is the ?running-around property?, namely the value of the players minus their depreciation. There are not many assets left after BVB has sold the stadium. Since the value of the squad is probably quite low, due to falling transfer sums, there are enormous debts, aren?t there?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: ?Running-around property? is good; I need to remember that one. Seriously it is like this: One side of the balance describes the origins of the means, or, to keep it simple: who owns the money. The other side states what one does with the money. For example, I went to the bank and loaned a credit over 1,000 Euros. Then on the passive side of the balance appears a liability of 1,000 Euros. For this money I buy a cupboard. That one appears on the active side of the balance. Because I use the cupboard its value decreases, so I use depreciations.
It is right that the transfer sums for players keep falling. The offers for Rosicky and Koller showed that. At least those were not the sums that management had calculated with. Otherwise one or two of the players would have been sold. One also has to remember that some contracts expire to the end of the season and the players would be able to change without a transfer fee.
Also true is also that I estimate the debts will rise to approximately 150 Mio Euro at the end of the last fiscal year. This estimation are based on the interim report of December 31st, 2003, which then has been extrapolated by me. This is a huge amount of debts, that has to be reduced in the future. Just regarding the interests you will see that at 8% interest rate the club has to pay 1 Mio each month or 12 Mio Euro a year. Adding to that the debts must be paid back, then there is the leasing rate of 12 to 17 Mio Euro for the stadium and the leasing back of the Goool.de brand which is 1.4 Mio Euro at minimum. Looking on a possible worst case: Then BVB have to pay 30 Mio Euro a year without having paid a single cent for player salaries and equipment. Not mentioning away matches. Whether we have to deal with over-indebtedness or not, only Dr Niebaum and Meier know, as they have the true figures. We have to wait till October to get to know the truth.
Schwatzgelb.de: Many supporters of BVB are not interested in shareholder value and financial circumstances as long as BVB show attractive football and play a major role in 1. Bundesliga. Many people are of the opinion that you are not interested in the club?s future on the pitch and think that there is something like a conspiracy against Borussia. Who do you want to explain to our users that the interests of the shareholders are the same like the ones of the supporters?
Stefan ten Doorkaat: Of course I can only speak for myself and the shareholders. We are concerned about the club?s future on the pitch as only with success the company can be turned healthy again. The question is just what is the right way to achieve this goal. Personally I favour the way VfB Stuttgart and Werder Bremen chose. Indeed BVB have another kind of tradition, but we have to realise the popularity those clubs achieved. That reminds me of BVB in the early 90?s. The finances and sporting future of BVB are in lockstep. When there is no money to be spent, I can?t afford good players. So it is definitely not a conspiracy against Borussia as I only react to the work at Rheinlanddamm (sg.com: Borussia?s headquarter). At the end the share quotation shows the degree of confidence of the shareholders in the company and its management.
Schwatzgelb.de: In one of your recent dossiers you blame Mr Meier for ?voodoo accounting? and accuse Mr Niebaum to tell fairy-tails. That?s a bit thick. Would you or will you call for the resignation of both?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: Talking about fairy-tales I can tell you that the board was addressed by me regarding an interview on the club?s own webpage ?BVB die Aktie? (sg.com: ?BVB the share?). Hereby I quoted statements of Mr Niebaum who is talking or let write about ?bridgeover financing?. To my astonishment I received a response that it wasn?t a financing deal but an ?interim solution?. It was just misunderstood by the interviewer. Adding to that the interview wasn?t authorised for going online. When I hear things like these, I am totally confused. Does Dr Niebaum give interview without making sure that the interview got everything right? Especially as this is a delicate subject, the selling of the naming rights of the Westfalenstadion. The interview is now 2 months on BVB?s homepage without being authorised? To me that sounds more like ?Gebrüder Grimm? (sg.com: Grimm brother, famous German mediaeval fairy-tellers) than a CEO of a stock-listed company.
For me ?voodoo accounting? is creating values through business, that nobody wants to fulfil. That is what happened with the stadium?s naming rights. In the mentioned interview Mr Dr Niebaum says that he doesn?t want this deal (sg.com: selling the naming rights) at all and of course not at this price. The Commerzbank just told that they have acquired the naming rights but without having made plans yet what to do with it. That is like buying a pizza and afterwards starting to think whether you are hungry or even like pizza.
Schwatzgelb.de: With exception of some supporters shouting ?Vorstand raus? (sg.com: ?board step down?) at the Wolfsburg home match the mood of the fans is still sedate. Mainly because there are not really alternatives to Mr Niebaum and Meier, there are next to no fans calling for the board to step down. Without talking about names, what qualities should a successor have? Are we talking about a complete cleaning up of the BVB KgaA? And how would that effect the future on the pitch?
Stefan ten Doornkaat: Let?s have a look at VfB Stuttgart. The were in the same situation and thought that there would not a future without former club president Gerhard Mayer-Vorfelder. Finally they found a new president and in my opinion he makes a good job. A successor has to be a true supporter of BVB, who loves the club with all his heart. At the same time he has to realise the necessity of financial recovery and should have the ability to set off a financial reorganisation. If this happens, success on the pitch will come back. Because that is clear to me: you can?t buy success, you have to work hard for it. That is in real life the same as in football, otherwise Bayern Munich with its big budget would be Bundesliga champions every single season.
Geschrieben von Guido