Football supporters of Germany, unite!

Last week, for the first time in Germany a protest march of active supporters took place in Berlin. The place was well chosen, because due to the German cup-final there were a lot of supporters and media representatives to be expected, and this could create a good impact on the public interest. Beforehand, one was taking guesses on how many people might join the demonstration. Quite a lot of people just thought of about 1,000 demonstrators. More than that seemed to be a lucky guess, because the demands and problems of the supporters are just to complicated and strange to those who seldom go to any away-match.


It was quite clear, that the ultras were going to play the major part in the march; not a wonder because it was during the germany-wide ultra-conference in Frankfurt when the idea was born. Obviously, the members of the law-enforcement and the DFL (the official German board to commercialize football) couldn't have imagined that it is possible that German supporters might as well form a unity that would overcome the borders between football clubs. But as matter of fact, it's their own fault, that something they didn't want did come true. In Italy, a similar demonstration failed because the supporters of the joining clubs were not just talking to one another....
Firstly, the police was not holding back (as it was discussed), but they were eager to check some of the banners. You can ask yourself, if the same would have happened during the protest march of some workers' union. Well, they're just football supporters, who cares.

After some opening words by the Berlin organization committee, Marc (from Bochum) gave some impressions of the typical treatment during an away-match. Following him, Uli (from the Phoenix Sons Karlsruhe) was singing some songs in which he was commenting the treatment of supporters (e.g. something similar to 'football without supporters is like fish without chips'). He being a supporter of a team that plays in second division is even more affected by the actions of DSF ('Deutsches Sport Fernsehen' i.e.'German Sports Television') than supporters of teams of first division are by the actions of the German Pay-TV ('Premiere'). After that, the crowd was in the right mood to get going.

Though all of the groups were asked to take their banners with them, unfortunately just a few did so.
The march went form the Alexanderplatz through the city center of Berlin and 'Unter den Linden' to arrive at the Alexanderplatz after 2 hours. During the march, Thomas 'Tower' Weinmann (from Mönchengladbach) held a speech in which he pointed out that on the other hand, supporters and ultras will have to make some sacrifices: It must be put an end to smoke and bengalos, because otherwise the police will always have a handy excuse for some of their actions. It will be interesting to find out how some groups and individuals rate the importance of their pyromania. On the other hand, by many fans this pyromania is regarded as the last chance to draw some attention to them. Often, banners are - among other things - forbidden, so there's only 'dust powder' left to make some sort of statement. And it is by far easier to pass the security check with some dust powder than with a large banner.
The march was interrupted from time to time for some action, e.g. the 'Uffta' (in Dortmund we call this 'Humba') and some singing: 'Everything but football is shitty' or 'Fish and Chips'; it was a very peaceful demonstration.

Of course, one has to admit that the body count of 2,500 participants seemed to be quite small, considering that there were about 60,000 football supporters in Berlin from Leverkusen and Gelsenkirchen. Not to forget those fans of the Berlin teams and the nearby Babelsberg and Cottbus. But then, do not forget that the demonstration had been originally planned by the ultras and therefore mostly ultras attended the demonstration. Most of the 'normal' fans didn't even know of the demonstration. And to be honest, most of them aren't even affected by the problems because they seldom go to away-matches.

Now, talking about the image of the ultras in the media. Ultras do not really exist there, their choreos aren't mentioned or shown; and if so they're shown that are not related to the ultras. If Ultras are mentioned, it's mostly talked about Italian ultras of Lazio Rome or Hellas Verona who are strongly inspired politically whereas German ultras are mostly not engaged in politics of any sort. Which leads the left-wing newspaper TAZ to the thesis that just because of that they are probably right-winged nationalists anyway. When talking about the demonstration, they're adding 'facts' to support their thesis: the participants had short hair and wore sneakers, polo-shirts and jeans. Yeah, right! Congrats to the TAZ's selective perception combined with superficiality and ignorance. In just another article, they're talking about the Lonsdale-myth to prove the political intentions of the ultras. No word about the fact that there were a lot of fans from clubs with a more left-wing supporter scene. No mentioning of the Che-Guevara-Shirts or the ones with the red star. Now words about the fact that in other countries such demonstrations often fail due to violent actions whereas in Germany this does not seem to be of much importance. But obviously, for some German media this whole discussion is not interesting enough to provide oneself with profound information.
'Ultras' are one of the few active fan movements in Germany in a time when most fans merely sit on their sofas, when the term 'fan' - that once came from 'fanatic' - now refers to everybody who's ever bought a scarf with some club motive on it. Can this demonstration and similar actions (e.g. the Pro-15:30-movement that is supported by a lot of fan groups) become a starting point to a new movement within the stadiums? Well, we'll see!

The participants of the Berlin demonstration had their reasons to march, to show and to fight for their way to live football. Thousands of other fans also live football - with all their differences - but they haven't started to fight yet. Probably because of some sort of resignation or because they haven't realized what has happened to football and what is going to happen in the near future.
The fan culture broke down during the last years without any consequences or regrets from the clubs or the media. It seems that they prefer a crowd just like the one in a U.S.-American-football-stadium. Just listen to Mr. Blatter and his fellows and you get an idea what we have to expect for 2006. No beer, because in the opera you don't drink beer either, no banners, no atmosphere. Instead, there'll be cheerleaders, music out of the box so everyone can only listen to songs that are family-compatible. Football, once a sport with deep emotional links to the soul of the supporters, is going to get perverted, it is going to mutate into a U.S. sports show.

And this is already being put in practice by the DFL. During the championship ceremony in the Westfalenstadion, loud music by selected artists came out of the loudspeakers, the crowd was just serving as staffage. Those who like that, please just sit on your benches and be quiet for 90 minutes - but, please, no whistling either! That's what the new football is creating: a crowd to that football is just a service (and the crowd being the customer). And bad service creates a negative reaction on the customer's side. Now, the officials realize that negative reactions by the crowd are not good for business. Therefore they introduce artificial measures to create a positive impression for those who finance their pay-checks: the industry. Cheerleaders, deafening, stupid music and some crappy mascots are just the start.

Until 2006, all stadiums are going to be alike. Those who just want to sing and/or drink some beer are nowhere to be seen because they are just the ones that always look for trouble and fights and therefore are not welcome anymore. In every stadium, you'll get the same alcohol-free(?) beer, the same sausages, hamburgers, hot dogs, you name it. Please, no regional extravagances. The guest shall feel at home, a WorldCup in style of a hotel chain on Mallorca. But maybe that's just a nightmare and we just wake up in 2006 to celebrate a feast having the chance to get to know other cultures, people from all over the world and in exchange have the possibility to represent our country as a whole but also our regions with all their peculiarities. But a horror would be stadiums filled with people who had to pay much money and just stare on the ground for 90 minutes only to express their negative impressions if they ever have some: No banners, choreographies and atmosphere. Just some cheerleaders and paid fans in the 'fan block' as it happens right now in Japan/South Korea. Thanks, but no thanks!
Another point is the treatment of the guest supporters. They're put into the corners of the stadiums and are treated really bad. 'Hopefully, there are no guest supporters in the future' some architects seem to think. By the way, if they're put into some acustically bad areas there isn't any chance for a challenge between the two crowds which leads to a poor atmosphere again. The 'guests' are treated like cattle, photographed and taped on video. Just for their own safety, of course. Same reason for taking away cameras, megaphones, banners, etc. You could might as well throw them and that's of course a security risk! No differentiation, no professionality in this part of the big business football. Instead, security officials rather like to celebrate themselves for their rigid actions.
But is it true that modern stadiums provide a maximum amount of safety? Well, take the 'Arena auf Sch*lke': The revolving doors at the entrance that let pass only one person at a time may be useful concerning security matters when getting inside. But think of a panic situation when everybody's trying to get out at once. These doors may serve as a death trap. The same with the alley that leads into the guests' area: it takes a sharp corner, leads through a small tunnel then some stairs up and ends in front of a glass door. I do not even want to imagine a crowd desperately trying to get out of there until finally stopped by the revolving doors. Of course, there are two other doors that may be opened but if somebody - alas - drops the key? Or if it can't be found quickly? Or if there's just nobody in reach to open the doors? But the Arena does meet all standards of the FIFA for the WorldCup 2006. The Westfalenstadion is going to be equipped with just the same electronic entrance to make it 'safer', too. Other stadiums will follow. Also, the seats with their high back-rests hinder those who want to get out quickly, and the space between the rows is getting smaller, too, which makes movements more difficult. You think of a flight onto the ground? No way, now there are walls or ditches that will stop you on your way to the safe ground, something that should be possible after getting rid of the fences (after the Sheffield catastrophe).

But if we demand that those restrictive measures should be reduced where they are not useful, we only get the answer 'Security matters are not negotiable'. On the one hand, they restrict everything from the really dangerous bengalo over lighters to banners due to some security business but on the other hand a panicked crowd does not count as a safety problem? It seems that controlling the spectators and commercialization are seen as more important than the safety in the stadium.

Wake up and fight! Football was, is and must be for the people. Football is exciting to everyone no matter class, religion, race, social status or whatever. It shouldn't be just for families with popcorn and ice-cream. Football is more than 11 versus 11 for 90 minutes, it is more than a TV-show, it is more than 'bread and games'. Football belongs to us, too! Nobody denies that it is a big business today for the industry, but they shouldn't forget, that it was the people, the clubs, and the fans and not the industry who made this sport so popular (think of the origin of 'popular', i.e. the people). Without us, great clubs wouldn't have become great clubs!
 
 

Geschrieben von snej
Diesen Artikel teilen
Unterstütze uns mit steady